On Healing Lands, Birds Perch
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
Behind one of the Vietnam War’s most iconic Pulitzer Prize–winning photographs lies a story resonant with today’s global crises. Woven through voices of survivors, ON HEALING LAND, BIRDS PERCH meditates on memory, loss, and renewal confronting the enduring scars of war and the resilience of refugees rebuilding their lives.
On Healing Land, Birds Perch is a short documentary that tells the remarkable stories behind one of the most iconic photos in history, while acting as a portal into the “varied carols,” to borrow from Walt Whitman, of trauma and the American journey. This is the first documentary, from a Vietnamese born filmmaker that explores the continuing aftershocks of the Vietnam War from the perspectives of both sides of the war: North Vietnamese and South Vietnamese including Vietnamese Americans alive today. The story is told through the iconic Pulitzer winning photo of General Loan shooting a Communist Vietcong, Captain Lem in the head, two days after the 1968 Tet Offensive. With original interviews, these individuals, the daughter of the General Loan, the children of the executed, Captain Lem, and the son whose family was allegedly killed by the executed and his men, prior to his execution, share for the first time on camera the intense emotions this photo elicits even today and the impact it has had on their lives. While these individuals hold widely differing views on this photo, the film poignantly portrays that all have something in common: the lasting trauma from the War.
Credits and citation support are not available for this title yet.
A MARC record for this title is not available yet.
Distributor subjects
Documentary Films,Photography,Illness,Disease and Disorders,History of IdeasKeywords
00:00:09.605 --> 00:00:20.533
(music)
00:00:20.533 --> 00:00:24.037
- [Narrator] The so-called
Indochina War did come to an end,
00:00:24.037 --> 00:00:28.082
which left Vietnam divided
between a Communist North
00:00:28.082 --> 00:00:29.834
and an Anti-Communist South.
00:00:31.878 --> 00:00:35.423
The military forces of the
Communist North, the Việt Cộng,
00:00:35.423 --> 00:00:38.634
began to infiltrate the South
in ever increasing numbers.
00:00:38.634 --> 00:00:40.345
(guns shooting)
00:00:40.345 --> 00:00:41.637
- [Narrator] On the first two nights
00:00:41.637 --> 00:00:43.973
of the Tet Lunar New Year's,
00:00:43.973 --> 00:00:46.768
the Việt Cộng, violating
the truce agreed on
00:00:46.768 --> 00:00:50.063
for that holiday, struck
across the entire length
00:00:50.063 --> 00:00:51.189
of South Vietnam.
00:00:57.862 --> 00:01:01.324
(person speaks in Vietnamese)
00:01:01.324 --> 00:01:03.743
(gun shoots)
00:01:07.789 --> 00:01:09.874
- [Narrator] Within 24
hours, Eddie Adams' snapshot
00:01:09.874 --> 00:01:11.667
of a Việt Cộng guerrilla being executed
00:01:11.667 --> 00:01:13.711
made front pages around the world.
00:01:16.172 --> 00:01:19.592
- The first time I saw the photo,
00:01:20.802 --> 00:01:22.387
I was in 11th grade,
00:01:23.388 --> 00:01:25.264
I was horrified, I guess.
00:01:25.264 --> 00:01:26.391
That's my dad.
00:01:38.945 --> 00:01:40.196
- The first time I was shown
00:01:40.196 --> 00:01:45.034
that picture was in Time
Magazine by one of my uncle.
00:01:45.952 --> 00:01:47.912
That's the Viet Cong that killed your family.
00:01:50.706 --> 00:01:53.876
- [Narrator] The picture of
the execution so shocked people
00:01:53.876 --> 00:01:56.045
that people who hadn't
thought about the war
00:01:57.004 --> 00:01:59.173
suddenly got such a jolt.
00:01:59.173 --> 00:02:03.010
(crowd chanting indistinctly)
00:02:05.138 --> 00:02:06.389
- [Narrator] An unsettling image
00:02:06.389 --> 00:02:09.892
that won the 1969 Pulitzer Prize.
00:02:09.892 --> 00:02:12.562
- Pictures don't tell the whole story.
00:02:12.562 --> 00:02:13.438
You look at a photograph,
00:02:13.438 --> 00:02:15.148
you’re looking at one five-hundredth of a second
00:02:15.148 --> 00:02:17.024
or one two-hundred-and-fiftieth of a second,
00:02:18.192 --> 00:02:19.193
and it’s a moment
00:02:19.444 --> 00:02:21.362
you don’t see all sides of it.
00:02:34.709 --> 00:02:37.211
(somber music)
00:02:43.176 --> 00:02:45.178
(no audio)
00:02:47.346 --> 00:02:49.015
(birds chirping)
(engine rumbling)
00:02:59.025 --> 00:03:00.193
- [June] Okay.
00:03:02.445 --> 00:03:04.113
Bon appetit.
00:03:04.113 --> 00:03:05.823
- It's a small bowl of pho.
00:03:05.823 --> 00:03:08.784
- [Loc] It's nice to have
a dinner together, right?
00:03:10.286 --> 00:03:11.162
- [June] Oh, definitely.
00:03:11.162 --> 00:03:14.248
- Yes. We haven't eaten
together in a long time.
00:03:14.248 --> 00:03:16.250
I miss coming home to your food.
00:03:16.250 --> 00:03:17.293
- Yes.
00:03:17.293 --> 00:03:20.796
Yeah, I remember when
I went to grad school,
00:03:26.177 --> 00:03:27.428
- [Christine] Just American food?
00:03:27.428 --> 00:03:28.262
- Uh-huh.
00:03:29.138 --> 00:03:30.640
Uh, bratwurst.
00:03:30.640 --> 00:03:31.807
(all laughing)
00:03:31.807 --> 00:03:34.018
I share a lot about my childhood
00:03:34.018 --> 00:03:37.355
because I think my
childhood was so idyllic.
00:03:38.397 --> 00:03:40.274
I loved living in Vietnam.
00:03:40.274 --> 00:03:42.527
- I would love to visit Vietnam
00:03:42.527 --> 00:03:44.237
to see where you both grew up.
00:03:44.237 --> 00:03:48.699
- It's hard because Vietnam
now is so different.
00:03:48.699 --> 00:03:51.160
The Vietnam, where I grew
up, it's just a memory.
00:03:54.997 --> 00:03:57.166
- People from Vietnam
used to tell us stories
00:03:57.166 --> 00:03:58.751
about our grandparents.
00:03:58.751 --> 00:04:02.338
- They want to make sure that we know
00:04:02.338 --> 00:04:06.592
what happened during the years of war.
00:04:06.592 --> 00:04:10.179
- You know, our family has
always chosen the path of, like,
00:04:11.430 --> 00:04:14.475
just keeping silent on the subject.
00:04:14.475 --> 00:04:18.896
But now there's a new
generation, two new generations
00:04:18.896 --> 00:04:22.775
that come up who knew nothing
about the Vietnam War.
00:04:22.775 --> 00:04:25.570
- I can't imagine moving my whole life.
00:04:27.363 --> 00:04:30.866
So I'm very grateful
that you've given us all
00:04:30.866 --> 00:04:32.702
the opportunities that we have today.
00:04:38.583 --> 00:04:42.295
- This is our family when
the kids were very young.
00:04:42.295 --> 00:04:46.215
For Vietnamese families,
extremely important.
00:04:46.215 --> 00:04:50.011
But for us it's even more so.
00:04:51.262 --> 00:04:56.017
We as a family form a perimeter, a fence
00:04:56.017 --> 00:04:57.602
to protect ourselves.
00:04:57.602 --> 00:04:59.103
Here are my kids.
00:04:59.103 --> 00:05:01.606
I took this picture, (laughs)
00:05:01.606 --> 00:05:05.359
and I think they are the
sweetest and cutest things.
00:05:06.611 --> 00:05:12.366
When we came over, the
experience of being a refugee,
00:05:12.366 --> 00:05:17.371
being different, and then
with the experience of my dad.
00:05:17.997 --> 00:05:19.290
This is my dad.
00:05:20.124 --> 00:05:22.877
Having to deal with the publicity.
00:05:24.462 --> 00:05:27.673
My dad, I think of him every day.
00:05:30.551 --> 00:05:31.385
Every day.
00:05:38.017 --> 00:05:40.478
(music)
00:05:52.823 --> 00:05:56.911
- [Huấn] It is a combination
of New Year, Thanksgiving,
00:05:56.911 --> 00:05:59.163
Christmas roll into one.
00:06:15.221 --> 00:06:17.473
(music)
00:06:19.058 --> 00:06:22.978
- You get to have an
outfit made just for Tet.
00:06:22.978 --> 00:06:26.774
- Children receive a lot
of lì xì, red envelope
00:06:26.774 --> 00:06:30.194
with new money for good
luck and good health.
00:06:31.153 --> 00:06:32.738
It's a time of renewal,
00:06:34.156 --> 00:06:37.576
- But Tet 1968 was not like that.
00:06:39.245 --> 00:06:44.250
- Every year around Tet,
I start dreaming again
00:06:47.712 --> 00:06:49.088
(Huấn snivels)
00:06:49.088 --> 00:06:50.297
of this nightmare.
00:06:55.344 --> 00:06:58.681
(distant waves crashing)
00:06:58.681 --> 00:07:03.227
We have this tradition
during Tet on New Year's day,
00:07:03.227 --> 00:07:05.354
whoever it is, the
first to enter the house
00:07:05.354 --> 00:07:07.189
will bring the luck into the house.
00:07:08.941 --> 00:07:12.319
Usually, they would choose a person
00:07:12.319 --> 00:07:14.321
that will bring good luck, good fortune,
00:07:14.321 --> 00:07:16.907
good health to the family.
00:07:16.907 --> 00:07:18.284
They called it xông đất,
00:07:19.869 --> 00:07:22.455
first to enter the portal of the family.
00:07:24.206 --> 00:07:27.585
On New Year's day of 1968,
00:07:27.585 --> 00:07:30.337
I heard the firecracker outside.
00:07:30.337 --> 00:07:31.464
I was curious.
00:07:32.590 --> 00:07:34.925
I just opened the door, walked out,
00:07:34.925 --> 00:07:39.930
enjoying the views, and
then came back in again
00:07:41.098 --> 00:07:45.186
and I was the first one
to xông đất that year.
00:07:46.896 --> 00:07:49.106
My father saw that
00:07:49.106 --> 00:07:52.193
and basically just slapped me in the face.
00:07:53.027 --> 00:07:55.237
I was nine years old at that time,
00:07:56.280 --> 00:07:58.491
and to this day I still regret it.
00:08:00.868 --> 00:08:05.873
I still think that I brought...
00:08:07.833 --> 00:08:09.001
I still think that I'm the one
00:08:09.001 --> 00:08:10.753
who brought bad luck to the family.
00:08:12.129 --> 00:08:13.881
(music)
00:08:24.433 --> 00:08:27.186
(guns shooting)
00:08:30.397 --> 00:08:32.191
- [Narrator] Suddenly and without warning,
00:08:32.191 --> 00:08:34.819
the violence of war shattered
the peaceful celebration
00:08:34.819 --> 00:08:36.195
of the Lunar New Year.
00:08:36.195 --> 00:08:38.489
- [Narrator] The Việt Cộng
simultaneously attacked
00:08:38.489 --> 00:08:41.617
just about every major city
and town in South Vietnam.
00:08:41.617 --> 00:08:44.578
- [Narrator] The battle
now was for Saigon itself.
00:08:44.578 --> 00:08:46.539
- [Narrator] As many
as 12 North Vietnamese
00:08:46.539 --> 00:08:49.166
and Việt Cộng battalions
had taken the city.
00:08:49.166 --> 00:08:52.002
(children crying)
00:08:55.506 --> 00:08:58.592
- We were all awakened by our father
00:08:58.592 --> 00:09:01.428
and told us to get into a bunker.
00:09:02.680 --> 00:09:06.225
I was praying to God, "Please save us."
00:09:10.145 --> 00:09:11.313
But that didn't happen.
00:09:14.149 --> 00:09:16.694
I see some bright lights.
00:09:16.694 --> 00:09:21.532
The next thing is I found
myself on the floor bleeding.
00:09:22.616 --> 00:09:24.743
I was shot in the head.
00:09:24.743 --> 00:09:27.955
It pierced through my skull here
00:09:27.955 --> 00:09:31.208
and my brother,
00:09:31.208 --> 00:09:34.837
I can still see his belly was cut open
00:09:42.428 --> 00:09:48.601
and he was breathing hard.
00:09:48.601 --> 00:09:50.352
Some of his last breath.
00:09:51.061 --> 00:09:52.813
(music)
00:09:54.189 --> 00:09:57.776
And I hid between the sandbags.
00:09:57.776 --> 00:10:01.655
In the meantime, Việt Cộng,
they went through the house.
00:10:01.655 --> 00:10:06.577
They took out the beers
and they were eating,
00:10:06.577 --> 00:10:11.457
while my mom was laying there dying.
00:10:12.082 --> 00:10:13.709
(music)
00:10:13.709 --> 00:10:16.337
I listened to my mom crying out in pain
00:10:18.964 --> 00:10:23.010
for almost, seems like eternity.
00:10:24.929 --> 00:10:26.847
She suffered a lot.
00:10:29.600 --> 00:10:34.396
I can't erase that out of my memory.
00:10:39.318 --> 00:10:44.657
(typewriter clattering)
(drums playing)
00:10:49.161 --> 00:10:54.500
(typewriter clattering)
(drums playing)
00:11:12.851 --> 00:11:15.104
(somber music)
00:11:16.814 --> 00:11:19.358
- [Narrator] Việt Cộng
snipers and suicide commandos
00:11:19.358 --> 00:11:22.444
were holed up inside the embassy compound
00:11:22.444 --> 00:11:24.989
and firing from surrounding building.
00:11:24.989 --> 00:11:28.075
(guns shooting)
00:11:28.075 --> 00:11:29.785
- [Narrator] Now the Việt
Cộng have carried the war
00:11:29.785 --> 00:11:32.997
into the cities, and there
seems to be no place to hide
00:11:32.997 --> 00:11:34.581
from the bombs and the bullets.
00:11:36.125 --> 00:11:37.251
- [Narrator] Almost predictably,
00:11:37.251 --> 00:11:38.877
the South Vietnamese reacted
00:11:38.877 --> 00:11:41.547
to the surprise attack
by arresting anyone
00:11:41.547 --> 00:11:43.966
who couldn't prove his
loyalty to the government.
00:11:45.259 --> 00:11:46.969
- [Huấn] The first time I saw the photo
00:11:46.969 --> 00:11:50.681
of my family was in Time Magazine.
00:11:50.681 --> 00:11:52.141
- [Narrator] Government
troops were ordered
00:11:52.141 --> 00:11:55.144
to get as much revenge as they could.
00:11:55.144 --> 00:11:56.812
(guns shooting)
00:11:56.812 --> 00:11:58.731
- [Huấn] It was shown to me by my uncle.
00:11:58.731 --> 00:12:00.232
He showed me also the picture
00:12:00.232 --> 00:12:03.485
executing one of the Việt Cộng.
00:12:03.485 --> 00:12:05.946
- [Narrator] Government troops
had captured the commander
00:12:05.946 --> 00:12:08.657
of the Việt Cộng Commando unit.
00:12:08.657 --> 00:12:11.744
- He told me that that was
the Viet Cong that killed my family
00:12:12.619 --> 00:12:14.830
and I was thinking in my
mind is, how does he know
00:12:14.830 --> 00:12:16.915
that that's the guy who killed my family?
00:12:18.625 --> 00:12:20.085
(gun bangs)
00:12:20.085 --> 00:12:22.337
(somber music)
00:12:28.635 --> 00:12:30.888
(somber music)
00:13:47.714 --> 00:13:50.551
In Washington today,
an echo of the Vietnam War,
00:13:50.551 --> 00:13:53.429
the U.S. government wants to deport a refugee
00:13:53.429 --> 00:13:55.430
General Nguyễn Ngọc Loan,
00:13:55.430 --> 00:13:58.433
once chief of the National
Police of South Vietnam.
00:13:58.433 --> 00:14:00.018
He is remembered for having shot
00:14:00.018 --> 00:14:02.354
and killed a man in the streets of Saigon.
00:14:02.354 --> 00:14:03.730
The immigration service calls
00:14:03.730 --> 00:14:06.066
that moral turpitude and wants him out.
00:14:06.066 --> 00:14:07.109
- [Reporter] Today, the former general
00:14:07.109 --> 00:14:09.361
runs a small restaurant
in Burke, Virginia,
00:14:09.361 --> 00:14:11.196
just outside of Washington,
00:14:11.196 --> 00:14:13.323
and now the government
wants to deport him.
00:14:18.537 --> 00:14:22.249
- You know, I probably
had the same reaction
00:14:22.249 --> 00:14:25.085
that any normal person would have,
00:14:26.378 --> 00:14:27.629
which is horror.
00:14:34.595 --> 00:14:37.264
But then, you know, I know my dad.
00:14:44.855 --> 00:14:48.483
He's somebody who's
extremely generous and kind,
00:14:48.483 --> 00:14:51.487
somebody who put their family first
00:14:51.487 --> 00:14:53.572
and put their country first.
00:14:53.572 --> 00:14:55.199
When I think of my dad, I think
00:14:55.199 --> 00:14:59.745
of all the pictures showing
his love for his grandchildren
00:14:59.745 --> 00:15:02.414
and here he is holding my son.
00:15:03.916 --> 00:15:07.002
When I first heard about
it, it was everywhere.
00:15:07.002 --> 00:15:10.547
It was in the news. It
was discussed in school.
00:15:11.548 --> 00:15:15.677
The kids in the class
had that horrified look,
00:15:17.638 --> 00:15:21.600
that "What kind of a person is your dad?"
00:15:28.190 --> 00:15:33.195
- It's beautiful. Walking
through this is really zen.
00:15:34.655 --> 00:15:36.573
As a child, that's probably one
00:15:36.573 --> 00:15:39.451
of my happiest time in Vietnam.
00:15:40.410 --> 00:15:42.663
Trees all around you,
00:15:42.663 --> 00:15:45.457
make you forget about
all the life trouble.
00:15:47.125 --> 00:15:49.836
I used to just lie down like this,
00:15:49.836 --> 00:15:53.173
looking up and looking
in the cloud floating by
00:15:53.173 --> 00:15:55.842
and just imagine that I'm one of the cloud
00:15:55.842 --> 00:15:59.972
and just daydreaming all day long.
00:15:59.972 --> 00:16:01.056
I feel connected.
00:16:04.184 --> 00:16:06.895
I feel like I'm part of the surrounding
00:16:06.895 --> 00:16:09.147
that just make me happy.
00:16:15.362 --> 00:16:17.322
Yeah, being here like
this is just bring back
00:16:17.322 --> 00:16:19.741
a lot of the good memory that I had.
00:16:23.537 --> 00:16:25.330
(music)
00:16:25.998 --> 00:16:30.794
I try to recall the good
time with my mom, my dad,
00:16:30.794 --> 00:16:32.587
my family in Vietnam.
00:16:32.587 --> 00:16:36.842
It's just override with all
of these painful memories.
00:16:38.093 --> 00:16:41.263
The happier time seemed to fade faster.
00:16:42.472 --> 00:16:46.768
I don't remember what my
brother and sisters like,
00:16:46.768 --> 00:16:51.606
what my dad or my mom
smelled like, their voice.
00:16:52.983 --> 00:16:56.445
To think about them in a peaceful way,
00:16:56.445 --> 00:16:57.946
it's just almost impossible.
00:16:59.072 --> 00:17:01.783
What I recall was what happened to them.
00:17:02.826 --> 00:17:04.828
It's just like, just happened yesterday.
00:17:05.704 --> 00:17:06.788
It never goes away.
00:17:08.415 --> 00:17:11.043
(traffic humming)
00:17:11.043 --> 00:17:13.879
I wrote this when I went back to Vietnam.
00:17:14.838 --> 00:17:18.008
The taxi weave its way from the airport
00:17:18.008 --> 00:17:20.385
threading through the
tangled maze of the city.
00:17:22.387 --> 00:17:26.641
A park came into view, striking
a chord of familiarity.
00:17:26.641 --> 00:17:29.353
I leaned forward and asked the cab driver,
00:17:29.353 --> 00:17:32.856
"Isn't that the former
Mạc Đĩnh Chi cemetery?"
00:17:40.113 --> 00:17:41.907
The memory came rushing back.
00:17:47.079 --> 00:17:50.957
I recognized that that
park was the old cemetery
00:17:52.167 --> 00:17:54.086
where my family was buried.
00:17:55.504 --> 00:18:00.467
I barely remember what happened that day.
00:18:04.679 --> 00:18:06.515
I was like a zombie.
00:18:08.100 --> 00:18:10.268
I don't even feel pain at that point.
00:18:12.104 --> 00:18:13.480
I'm just lost.
00:18:18.360 --> 00:18:22.280
My guilt is I'm the one who caused it all,
00:18:22.280 --> 00:18:24.783
'cause I bring bad luck to the family.
00:18:26.493 --> 00:18:28.412
I still regret it to this day.
00:18:30.956 --> 00:18:32.791
Guilt that I survive.
00:18:35.335 --> 00:18:37.629
I feel like God is punishing me.
00:18:40.215 --> 00:18:41.925
I wish that I could be with them.
00:18:44.052 --> 00:18:45.303
I wish that all the time.
00:18:46.763 --> 00:18:49.516
(birds chirping)
00:18:57.107 --> 00:18:59.860
(engine humming)
00:19:09.744 --> 00:19:13.331
- My parents' restaurant was
right here with this door.
00:19:13.331 --> 00:19:14.791
There was no door here.
00:19:14.791 --> 00:19:17.836
That was the front and
that's the mall entrance.
00:19:19.171 --> 00:19:24.176
My parents were working seven
days a week for several years.
00:19:24.259 --> 00:19:28.054
You know, there were all these
extracurricular activities
00:19:28.054 --> 00:19:31.016
through high school
that I didn't belong to,
00:19:31.016 --> 00:19:33.894
because I had to go home
and work at a restaurant.
00:19:34.936 --> 00:19:37.189
That became our lives.
00:19:39.691 --> 00:19:43.153
Life was difficult enough
trying to make a living
00:19:43.153 --> 00:19:46.823
without having to deal
with this extra stress
00:19:46.823 --> 00:19:49.784
of the deportation hearings.
00:19:52.787 --> 00:19:57.209
I was angry that this
is happening to my dad
00:19:57.209 --> 00:19:58.668
and to our family.
00:20:00.962 --> 00:20:04.299
To send him back would be
to essentially send him
00:20:05.509 --> 00:20:06.510
to be killed.
00:20:09.763 --> 00:20:13.141
I remember seeing graffiti
a lot in the restrooms,
00:20:14.309 --> 00:20:15.769
four letter words,
00:20:16.770 --> 00:20:21.316
and my dad described as a war criminal.
00:20:22.317 --> 00:20:26.696
It made me make a resolve to work hard,
00:20:26.696 --> 00:20:28.406
to not have to deal with all that.
00:20:29.783 --> 00:20:34.746
I got accepted to UVA, but my dad got sick
00:20:34.746 --> 00:20:37.958
and I told him maybe I
should stay and help.
00:20:39.209 --> 00:20:41.378
My dad said, "No way."
00:20:43.588 --> 00:20:44.965
We were refugees
00:20:44.965 --> 00:20:47.884
and he knew that the only way
00:20:47.884 --> 00:20:50.971
that we could dig ourselves
out of this poverty
00:20:50.971 --> 00:20:55.350
that we were in is for us kids
00:20:55.350 --> 00:20:57.018
to get an education.
00:20:59.437 --> 00:21:03.858
I felt very relieved when
President Carter decided
00:21:03.858 --> 00:21:07.988
that the whole deportation
issue should be dropped.
00:21:09.864 --> 00:21:14.244
When I went to college I could
leave all of that behind,
00:21:16.746 --> 00:21:20.959
escaping being the
daughter of General Loan
00:21:23.295 --> 00:21:25.005
and be my own person.
00:22:57.806 --> 00:23:00.350
- This is always a quest for me,
00:23:01.226 --> 00:23:04.145
trying to piece together my life,
00:23:05.313 --> 00:23:08.566
my life of them, how it was.
00:23:10.568 --> 00:23:14.072
I feel there's no justice in the world.
00:23:16.241 --> 00:23:20.036
Sure, the execution is
very, very traumatic,
00:23:20.036 --> 00:23:23.998
but this is just one
single act of atrocity.
00:23:23.998 --> 00:23:26.501
It captured your attention,
00:23:26.501 --> 00:23:28.795
but the true casualties of war here
00:23:28.795 --> 00:23:31.506
are the women and the children.
00:23:32.424 --> 00:23:36.261
At least 15,000 civilian deaths
happened during that time.
00:23:38.513 --> 00:23:40.974
The picture of that Eddie Adams took,
00:23:40.974 --> 00:23:42.475
changed the course of the war.
00:23:42.475 --> 00:23:44.352
It changed the perception of the war.
00:23:45.437 --> 00:23:48.022
- [Narrator] Radicals shouted
support for the Vietnam.
00:23:49.315 --> 00:23:51.901
- But if you compare the two, right, one
00:23:51.901 --> 00:23:54.446
between the two combatant on the field,
00:23:54.446 --> 00:23:58.616
despite Việt Cộng wearing
civilian clothing,
00:23:58.616 --> 00:24:02.746
and the photo of my whole
family that was massacred,
00:24:04.164 --> 00:24:06.458
which one is more atrocious?
00:24:08.960 --> 00:24:11.713
And why is it that that's
not the frontline picture?
00:24:15.675 --> 00:24:19.137
I think that the public
opinion will be different then.
00:25:04.140 --> 00:25:05.767
- The picture is a picture,
00:25:05.767 --> 00:25:08.895
but it doesn't tell the entire story.
00:25:08.895 --> 00:25:13.107
The picture doesn't show what
happened before the photo.
00:25:14.275 --> 00:25:18.071
The picture doesn't show
that this guy has been going
00:25:18.071 --> 00:25:22.992
through town ordering, people
killed, killing people.
00:25:24.494 --> 00:25:27.705
Until you are a soldier,
00:25:27.705 --> 00:25:30.875
you cannot understand
00:25:30.875 --> 00:25:33.545
how they react to things.
00:25:33.545 --> 00:25:36.714
I can imagine my dad standing
right there seeing it,
00:25:38.675 --> 00:25:41.052
just how it would've affected him.
00:25:42.178 --> 00:25:46.349
You do not have their
experiences with war.
00:25:48.393 --> 00:25:49.894
- I don't know what I would do.
00:25:50.770 --> 00:25:55.358
I hope that I would be able
to have that discipline
00:25:55.358 --> 00:25:56.860
to not shoot the guy.
00:26:15.587 --> 00:26:19.090
- If you tell me,
identify him as the person
00:26:19.090 --> 00:26:20.341
that killed my family,
00:26:21.718 --> 00:26:25.179
I will say that I cannot
testify to that fact.
00:26:26.681 --> 00:26:28.683
I can't see his face.
00:26:30.435 --> 00:26:32.520
I'm speaking from a nine
years old perspective.
00:26:32.520 --> 00:26:33.813
I don't remember.
00:26:35.315 --> 00:26:36.566
- Even though I look at the picture
00:26:36.566 --> 00:26:38.484
and I see the horror in it,
00:26:41.154 --> 00:26:43.615
I don't see my dad as the
person in the picture,
00:26:43.615 --> 00:26:46.409
I see him as an entire person
00:26:46.409 --> 00:26:49.078
with all the experience I had with him.
00:26:54.125 --> 00:26:59.130
So I don't question
00:27:00.089 --> 00:27:01.090
what he did.
00:27:13.978 --> 00:27:16.940
- I have so much connection to this place.
00:27:16.940 --> 00:27:19.442
It's a place of reflection.
00:27:19.442 --> 00:27:24.072
Speak to me from a
connection to the old country,
00:27:24.072 --> 00:27:28.660
from a perspective of my new adopted home.
00:27:35.124 --> 00:27:37.669
I was lucky enough to be able to come here
00:27:37.669 --> 00:27:41.214
to America as refugee.
00:27:41.214 --> 00:27:43.466
That doesn't happen all
the time to everyone.
00:27:46.594 --> 00:27:49.514
We became part of this American fabric
00:27:49.514 --> 00:27:51.516
that we are building today.
00:27:53.726 --> 00:27:56.854
Joining the Navy is because
I want to repay that debt.
00:27:59.732 --> 00:28:03.236
I always wanted to
continue my father's legacy
00:28:04.445 --> 00:28:09.033
to do the thing that my
family would be proud of me.
00:28:09.033 --> 00:28:11.995
It is a great honor to attain the rank of Admiral,
00:28:11.995 --> 00:28:16.582
and I’m tremendously humbled to become the
first Vietnamese American
00:28:16.582 --> 00:28:20.086
to wear the flags insignia of
the United States Navy.
00:28:27.135 --> 00:28:28.469
The refugees, we all go
00:28:28.469 --> 00:28:29.721
through the same steps.
00:28:30.805 --> 00:28:32.181
We all come over here.
00:28:32.181 --> 00:28:36.394
We all have to deal with all
the trauma that we experience,
00:28:37.645 --> 00:28:40.023
leaving our homeland,
00:28:41.315 --> 00:28:43.276
figuring out how to fit in,
00:28:44.986 --> 00:28:46.779
whether you ever fit in.
00:28:49.741 --> 00:28:51.242
What does it mean to be Vietnamese
00:28:51.242 --> 00:28:54.871
after 50 years not visiting Vietnam?
00:28:59.834 --> 00:29:02.754
Once you become very sure of yourself,
00:29:04.338 --> 00:29:08.885
you found yourself, you can have peace
00:29:08.885 --> 00:29:13.890
and be able to say, "Even
though I am an American,
00:29:16.476 --> 00:29:18.061
I'm a Vietnamese at heart.
00:29:20.480 --> 00:29:22.065
(music)
00:29:24.567 --> 00:29:29.572
- When the Vietnamese diaspora,
they lost the war, they came here.
00:29:30.448 --> 00:29:34.243
They never had a chance to have closure.
00:29:55.139 --> 00:30:00.103
- You still see the trauma
of war on both sides,
00:30:02.271 --> 00:30:06.192
and so how do we
move forward togther?
00:30:33.511 --> 00:30:37.431
- Before I was very adamant
about not going back to Vietnam,
00:30:38.474 --> 00:30:43.479
because I felt that I
would be dishonoring my dad
00:30:49.068 --> 00:30:52.989
against communism and
protecting his country.
00:30:57.827 --> 00:31:00.955
But now, I've made peace with the fact
00:31:00.955 --> 00:31:04.709
that Vietnam is no longer the
Vietnam that I grew up in.
00:31:05.960 --> 00:31:09.005
My kids want to see Vietnam,
00:31:09.005 --> 00:31:12.717
where their parents came from.
00:31:12.717 --> 00:31:16.262
They've grown up with
the Vietnamese culture.
00:31:16.262 --> 00:31:19.765
They want to know their roots,
00:31:19.765 --> 00:31:21.809
and I think that
00:31:24.103 --> 00:31:26.731
I should not prevent that from happening.
00:31:32.653 --> 00:31:36.365
- Why I survive? Why me?
00:31:36.365 --> 00:31:38.201
That question always gnawed at me.
00:31:41.329 --> 00:31:45.416
I want that nine years
old little boy to move on
00:31:45.416 --> 00:31:47.668
and achieve greater things.
00:31:57.053 --> 00:31:58.346
(music)
00:31:59.764 --> 00:32:01.766
When I first came to the US,
00:32:01.766 --> 00:32:04.769
that's the first time I experienced peace
00:32:04.769 --> 00:32:06.979
and I'm wishing for
peace around the world.
00:32:10.024 --> 00:32:13.486
The Vietnamese will say
"Đất Lành Chim Đậu",
00:32:13.486 --> 00:32:18.115
it means that where you
have a blessed place,
00:32:18.115 --> 00:32:22.161
birds will stay there,
00:32:22.161 --> 00:32:24.497
will be there.
00:32:24.497 --> 00:32:27.208
(birds chirping)
00:32:35.675 --> 00:32:40.137
(music)
00:32:42.265 --> 00:32:46.727
(music)
00:32:51.023 --> 00:32:55.903
(birds chirping)
00:33:10.042 --> 00:33:14.505
(music)
00:33:21.595 --> 00:33:26.058
(music)
00:33:34.525 --> 00:33:38.988
(music)
00:33:49.373 --> 00:33:53.836
(music)
00:34:04.388 --> 00:34:08.851
(music)
00:34:18.194 --> 00:34:22.656
(music)
00:34:24.116 --> 00:34:28.996
(birds chirping)